Home > PPTA Blog > Tags > Tomorrow's Schools

The Pigeonhole

Welcome to the blog of the New Zealand Post Primary Teachers' Association / Te Wehengarua (PPTA), .... A blog that's not afraid to ruffle some feathers

For blog guidelines, click here

Tags >> Tomorrow's Schools

 

My feeling is that charter schools will be a defining issue for New Zealanders just like the tour was in the 1980s (now where was that nice Johnny Key on the issue – that’s right, he can’t remember …) and the bulk funding disputes of the 1990s.    The sides are lining up and the side of the angels is clearly the opposing one. Even the Teachers’ Council has bravely  (bravely because it is a crown entity) put out a release saying the introduction of American charter schools needs to be treated with some circumspection.  And then there was this wonderful piece from the Wellington Wairarapa School Trustees Association (WSTA) calling on the government to put “the public” back into public education.   

 


Dear Anne

I have just read your party education policy. This letter is written in disappointment that National Party education policy can so blithely ignore the best evidence in education research and policy, and dismay that you appear not to have heard the education hopes, dreams and aspirations that teachers have for their students.

National takes credit for all improvements in the education sector over the past three years; some achievements - such as retention rates in school, are unlikely to have been influenced by National education policy, others are simply manipulations such as 'employed 1600 more teachers"; shuffling funding from one education area to another doesn't double it; league tables encourage some particularly unpleasant uncooperative competitive behaviours so how on earth can your policy blithely state "ensure schools make the most of their facilities and resources and they collaborate rather than compete with each other" or does this only apply to Canterbury?

We'd like you to know that all actual improvements in the secondary education sector can be attributed to school communities, the hard work of parents, boards, students, teachers and, most importantly, quality teaching.


PPTA president Robin Duff responds to the challenge of PPTA being 'dreamers' if we really think politicians of all stripes can work together for a better future for New Zealand students and our education system.

"Dream on"

Firstly, 'dream on' is quite a perceptive comment in that I believe that much of my work has, is and perhaps always will be based on 'dreams' for education as much as it was/is for other areas of my life.

The dream actually motivates and drives us all.


The NZ School Trustees Association has been celebrating 21 years of its existence by claiming credit for other peoples’ work.  Apparently, it is entirely responsible for progress made in educational achievement in New Zealand schools.

 

I don’t wish to denigrate individual boards of trustees who give up many hours of their own time to do what department of education officials once received a salary for doing, but it stretches credibility to imagine that student achievement is influenced in any significant way by governance arrangements.   


 

Don Brash is famous for two things

By ToilandTrouble

  1. His willingness to use race in order to advance his campaign for political power in 2005, and:
  2. His ability to survive for many weeks on a diet of corned beef and frozen peas.

He is also an economist and we know how many of them it takes to change a light bulb (none, the darkness will cause the light bulb to change itself).  In sum he is overwhelmingly under-qualified to comment on educational matters.  That doesn't matter though because economists are immune to intellectual humility,  untroubled by their own ignorance and always ready to draw a crooked line from an unproved assumption to a forgone conclusion.

 


«StartPrev12NextEnd»