Prime Minister should apologise to all women as Government found to have breached human rights law
Today's High Court judgment exposes the Government’s pay equity changes for what they were - an attempt to cut costs at the expense of women, says Chris Abercrombie, PPTA Te Wehengarua president.
"The Prime Minister, Christopher Luxon, owes all women in Aotearoa New Zealand an apology. He needs to acknowledge that the pay equity system was working, but the Government dismantled it because the price of addressing historic undervaluation was one it did not want to pay.”
The Court stated that the teachers’ pay equity claim was specifically in the Government’s sights because of its potential cost. The Court found “the main driver was fiscal”, and that there was “nothing tangible” to support the claim that the previous pay equity system was not working as it should.
The Court has now declared that the Equal Pay Act, as amended in 2025, is inconsistent with the right under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act to be free from discrimination on the ground of sex.
Chris Abercrombie says the judgment is a powerful vindication for teachers. “Our claim wasn’t stopped because there was something wrong with it. It was targeted because recognising and addressing the historical undervaluation of teachers was going to cost too much.
“Teachers are busting their guts holding secondary education together. Right now, they’re carrying students through digital exams falling over, they’re facing an enormous reform agenda being pushed through at breakneck speed, including curriculum material riddled with AI slop, and all the while they are being treated with a breathtaking lack of respect for their professional expertise.
“And then, when teachers sought to test whether their own profession had been historically undervalued because it is predominantly women’s work, the Government changed the law and pulled the rug out from under them.
Chris Abercrombie says every political party seeking to form the next government now needs to take this judgment deadly seriously. "Women’s right to pay equity must never again be treated as a cost to be engineered away.
Last modified on Thursday, 19 November 2026 13:58